Munger Mode rating: 2 out of 5 — Sell. Our own rating from the research report below, on business quality first: moat durability and management, with price separating the top three.
Carnival is a better company than it was two years ago. It is also a cyclical, capital-hungry, leveraged ship operator in an industry where every competitor can buy the same ships from the same three yards. Management has repaired the balance sheet well. The shares trade at about 11 times 2026 guided earnings, which is cheap against the S&P 500 but not cheap for a business that nearly failed in 2020 and that must spend about $16 billion on new ships to keep growing. Here is how we apply our own rubric. The business is average, and its moat is real but narrow, built on scale. Management is competent and has shown good judgment since 2022. At $25 the discount to a reasonable estimate of value is perhaps 10 to 20 percent. That is not the "significant, quantified" discount we require to lift an average business to three stars. We would not initiate a position.
Recent filings analysed: 8-K (2026-11-04), 8-K (2026-09-29), 10-Q (2026-09-29), 8-K (2026-08-05).
Stock screener · Superinvestor 13F holdings · Analyst sentiment